What is the Public Information Act and what is a Public Information Request? Well, the Texas Public Information Act assures that government entities give citizens access to information about what the public servants are doing on their behalf. It is a way for citizens to hold their public officials accountable. The Public Information Act Handbook can be found on the Texas Attorney General’s website and lays out the “how-to” to do open record requests.
In Frisco, many of our city council members and mayor use their personal devices (cell phones) to communicate so the question becomes what is “public information” and what is subject to the act? If information was made, transmitted, maintained, or received in connection with a governmental body’s official business, the mere fact that the governmental body does not possess the information does not take the information outside the scope of the Act. Emails or text messages sent via personal email and personal devices if related to city business are subject to the act. Why is this important in Frisco? Several of our council members use their personal devices and personal emails regularly to conduct city business. When a request comes in, the city sends it to the individuals named and say do you have anything related to this PIR, if so please send it to us. It allows for dishonesty, if you don’t want someone to see an email you can simply not send it. It’s the Honor Code system.
In the ethics complaint we reviewed, Cheney wrote in his social media post “As a leader of a council that upholds transparency and full disclosure, I will provide them here without edit as they would appear in our official city records” so we decided to investigate the official record and his claims. We filed a PIR that read:
Per Cheney’s Facebook Post (Account: Mayor Jeff Cheney) dated May 25, 2021, he admits to sending an email posing a simple question to senior members of our Frisco City Staff: “In the runoff race which Place 3 candidates have asked to meet with you?” Each staff member was questioned separately using electronic media making their response part of the official city record and subject to public information requests. Based on that post I would like the following communications from May 23, 2021 – May 26, 2021 :
1. All Electronic Media communications (including email, text, Facebook/Facebook messenger from Mayor Jeff Cheney’s official account) and City Manager George Purefoy
2. All Electronic Media communications (including email, text, Facebook/Facebook messenger from Mayor Jeff Cheney’s official account) and Police Chief David Shilson
3. All Electronic Media communications (including email, text, Facebook/Facebook messenger from Mayor Jeff Cheney’s official account) and Fire Chief Mark Piland
4. All Electronic Media communications (including email, text, Facebook/Facebook messenger from Mayor Jeff Cheney’s official account) and Henry Hill, Deputy City Mgr
5. All Electronic Media communications (including email, text, Facebook/Facebook messenger from Mayor Jeff Cheney’s official account) and Ben Brezina, Asst City Mgr
6. All Electronic Media communications (including email, text, Facebook/Facebook messenger from Mayor Jeff Cheney’s official account) and Jason Cooley, Ph.D. – Chief Information Officer
7. All Electronic Media communications (including email, text, Facebook/Facebook messenger from Mayor Jeff Cheney’s official account) and Ron Patterson, President Frisco Economic Development Corporation
8. All Electronic Media communications (including email, text, Facebook/Facebook messenger from Mayor Jeff Cheney’s official account) and Marla Roe, Executive Director Visit Frisco
9. All Electronic Media communications (including email, text, Facebook/Facebook messenger from Mayor Jeff Cheney’s official account) and John Lettellier, Director of Development Services
10. All Electronic Media communications (including email, text, Facebook/Facebook messenger from Mayor Jeff Cheney’s official account) and Paul Knippel, Director of Public Works
The response to our PIR was 7 pages, the first 2 were a copy of the post from his page and the remaining pages contained 4 text messages between the mayor and 4 senior staff members. Problem #1 it appears we received an incomplete PIR request from the city. So where are the remaining 6 text message communications? Problem #2 Cheney quoted Marla Roe, Executive Director Visit Frisco on his social media post as saying “Just Angelia. Had a great conversation. Henry was there.” However, after receiving our PIR Marla Roes actual statement via text said, “Just Angelia. Had a great conversation. Henry was there. Will say Jennifer stopped by my house and I told her I worked for the city. Not much else. With Angelia was via teams FYI.” Why is this important, he left out that the other candidate had interacted with the city employee. One via door knocking and one via Microsoft Teams. Does not seem like a big deal but when it comes to transparency – it is a very big deal!
We want to believe our elected officials are good people, honest people, and forthcoming. The truth is we don’t know and that is why the act is so important because it allows us that transparency. Transparency should never be based on the honor system. Not everyone is honorable! That is how they can hide the shady shit!
This guy lies when the truth sounds better. And it’s been going on for years.